Brew City Insurance, South Milwaukee, WI

Brew City Insurance
2937 S. Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: 414-762-6600

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Insurance
    • Car Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Condo Insurance
    • Boat Insurance
    • Motorcycle Insurance
    • RV & Camper Insurance
    • ATV & UTV Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Umbrella Insurance
    • Small Business Insurance
  • Blog
  • Service
  • Contact
  • Online Quote

Customer Service

Our Door Is Always Open

You can reach us in person, by phone, or by email. After business hours, we regularly check our voicemail to make sure we can respond in the case of an emergency. Contact us anytime you have a question about your bill, coverage, or even a “what if” scenario—whether you’re adding another driver, buying a new car, starting a business, purchasing a recreational vehicle, or welcoming a new family member. We’ll help you decide what coverage fits your situation.

When You Need Us

If you experience a loss, call our office right away. We’ll guide you through the claims process from start to finish. Whether you’re dealing with a cracked windshield or facing a house fire, we’ll work with you to repair or replace the covered loss. We commit ourselves to making sure you feel supported and satisfied with your choice of Brew City Insurance.

AAA

Photo of AAA
AAA Address 8401 Excelsior Boulevard Madison WI 53717 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-236-1300home Billing: 800-677-0777homefax Claims: 800-723-0220cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Acuity

Photo of Acuity
Acuity Address 2800 South Taylor Drive PO Box 58 Sheboygan WI 53082-0058 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 920-458-9131home Billing: 800-242-7666homefax Claims: 800-242-7666cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

American Modern

Photo of American Modern
American Modern Address P.O. Box 5323 Cincinnati OH 45201 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-543-2644home Billing: 800-543-2644homefax Claims: 800-375-2075cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Dairyland

Photo of Dairyland
Dairyland Address PO Box 8021 Stevens Point WI 54481-8021 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-334-0090home Website Billing Website Claims Website

Foremost

Photo of Foremost
Foremost Address PO Box 0915 Carol Stream IL 60132-0915 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-527-3905home Billing: 800-435-7764homefax Claims: 800-527-3907cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Germantown Mutual Insurance Company

Photo of Germantown Mutual Insurance Company
Germantown Mutual Insurance Company Address W209 N11845 Insurance Place P.O. Box 1020 Germantown WI 53022-8220 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 262-251-6680home Billing: 262-251-6680homefax Claims: 800-236-4642cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Hagerty

Photo of Hagerty
Hagerty Address P.O. Box 1303 Traverse City MI 49685-1303 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 877-922-9701home Billing: 888-220-9565homefax Website Billing Website Claims Website

Integrity Insurance

Photo of Integrity Insurance
Integrity Insurance Address 2121 East Capitol Drive PO Box 539 Appleton WI 54912-0539 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 866-550-9220home Billing: 888-699-9182homefax Claims: 800-445-3030cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Progressive

Photo of Progressive
Progressive Address 6300 Wilson Mills Rd Mayfield Village OH 44143 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 888-671-4405home Billing: 888-671-4405homefax Claims: 800-776-4737cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

West Bend

Photo of West Bend
West Bend Address 1900 S 18th Ave West Bend WI 53095 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-236-5010home Claims: 877-922-5246cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Contact

As you may have already read elsewhere on our site, Brew City Insurance has been a fixture in South Milwaukee area for a while. While we are located in South Milwaukee, Wisconsin, our agency also serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout the state of Wisconsin. 

Address

2937 S Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172

Phone

Phone: 414-762-6600

Fax

Fax: 414-762-6601

Email

  • debbie@brewcityinsurance.com
  • danielle@brewcityinsurance.com

Hours of Operation

Monday – Thursday: 8:30 – 4:30
Friday – 9:00 – 1:00
Saturday and Evening Hours by Appointment

Map

Get Directions

Add Waypoint
show options hide options
Print directions Reset directions
Fetching directions......
Reset directions
Print directions

Contact Us

Brew City Insurance
2937 S. Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: 414-762-6600

Our Hours

Mon - Thurs: 8:30 - 4:30
Friday: 9:00 - 1:00
Sat & Evenings By Appointment

Proud Member of

PIAW Couri Insurance Associates

Follow Brew City Insurance

Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon

Copyright © 2026 - Brew City Insurance Agency, Inc - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy - Sitemap