Brew City Insurance, South Milwaukee, WI

Brew City Insurance
2937 S. Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: 414-762-6600

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Insurance
    • Car Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Condo Insurance
    • Boat Insurance
    • Motorcycle Insurance
    • RV & Camper Insurance
    • ATV & UTV Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Umbrella Insurance
    • Small Business Insurance
  • Blog
  • Service
  • Contact
  • Online Quote

Welcome to Brew City Insurance!

Debbie and Danelle

Progressive
Acuity
AAA
GMIC
Hagerty
Integrity Insurance
Foremost
American Modern
Dairyland
West Bend

You Deserve a Choice

Hi! We’re Debbie and Dannielle from Brew City Insurance Agency Inc. We believe that insurance should be about more than just policies—it should be about people. As an independent insurance agency located in South Milwaukee, Wisconsin, we are dedicated to providing our clients with personalized service and comprehensive coverage options.​

Our Mission

Our mission is to offer customers a truly exceptional insurance buying experience. We provide our customers with the knowledge to choose the best possible insurance products that fulfill their wants and needs. Our friendly, knowledgeable, and professional staff will help inspire, problem-solve, and best of all, educate our customers so they can choose the coverage that best fits at a reasonable price.​

What We Offer

We specialize in a wide range of insurance products to meet the diverse needs of our clients:​

  • Home Insurance: Protect your home and personal property with comprehensive coverage options.​
  • Auto Insurance: From cars to motorcycles, we offer policies that keep you covered on the road.​
  • Life Insurance: Plan for the future and provide financial security for your loved ones.​
  • Business Insurance: Whether you’re a small business owner or run a large enterprise, we can help protect your business assets .​

As an independent agency, we have the flexibility to shop customers to several major insurance companies to ensure that you get the best coverage at the lowest possible rates .​

Our Commitment

We are committed to building lasting relationships with our clients. By treating every customer like they are a part of our family, we aim to provide a level of service that sets us apart. Our team is always here to answer your questions, review your policies, and assist with any claims to ensure a smooth and stress-free experience.​

Visit Us

Brew City Insurance Agency Inc. is conveniently located between Pick ‘n Save and Walgreens.

2937 S Chicago Ave.
South Milwaukee, WI 53172​

Stop in today and see what we can do for you!​

Brew City Insurance5.0
Based on 154 reviews
See all reviews
review us on
Chandler H.
3 weeks ago
I recommend Brew City Insurance to all my friends, it feels like someone really has your back! Debbie was able to find us a better plan for hundreds less than what we were paying. After our accident we were so nervous but they made it so smooth to connect us with a competent agent.
Sue Z.
1 month ago
I have been with Debbie since before she opened her own business. She has always been so helpful and caring. I recommend her big time to anyone needing a agent.
Suzanne
1 month ago
I've trusted Debbie Cook with my insurance needs for over 20 years, and couldn't be happier. I started out needing Renter's insurance, then Auto, then on to Homeowner's insurance & multi Auto ins.. I love that Brew City Ins. is conveniently located in South Milwaukee, & the 3 insurance agents available are equally knowledgeable, friendly, and sincerely care about your insurance needs, and the cost. It's very easy to reach them with questions any time. I definitely recommend Brew City Insurance to anyone in need of insurance. It costs nothing to get a quote, & is worth your time to experience the refreshing honesty & sincerity of this company.
Robert F.
1 month ago
Their the best!! I've referred several friends and family.
Chris Z.
1 month ago
Extremely helpful, and great communication. 6 stars if they had it
Thomas L.
7 months ago
Debbie returns all calls and answers questions and concerns...nice people to handle any issues been with Brew City a long time and will continue to do so
Patricia M.
7 months ago
Everyone at Brew City is so helpful and friendly!
Octavia S.
7 months ago
You are all so helpful! Thank you so much!
Raza K.
10 months ago
Debbie Larson Ma’am is very nice & good human being. She not only help me but she understand my accent. My accent is so hard and I have British English. She understood everything and she gave me very good rates for my insurance since I am new to United States. She knows my requirement thank you Debbie ma’am.
Mocha K.
11 months ago
I've had a peace of mind knowing that a reputable agency stands behind it's name! 🙌🏾

Contact Us

Brew City Insurance
2937 S. Chicago Ave
South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: 414-762-6600

Our Hours

Mon - Thurs: 8:30 - 4:30
Friday: 9:00 - 1:00
Sat & Evenings By Appointment

Proud Member of

PIAW Couri Insurance Associates

Follow Brew City Insurance

Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon

Copyright © 2026 - Brew City Insurance Agency, Inc - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy - Sitemap